I read about this on Yahoo's front page earlier today and was initially content with the Hathaway decision because, in the photo of her they had to go along with it, she looked like someone I could imagine playing Catwoman. Of course, as you point out, attitude is a major part of Catwoman's persona and I'm not sure Hathaway can pull that off. Still, it's hard for me to imagine playing the role poorly enough to make me wish it was someone else.

Holy crap, that was Rachel Weisz in The Mummy! I saw it in the theater and maybe once since, and only saw The Mummy Returns (which I thought was a piss poor sequel) in the theater. I didn't know who she was then. The first time I heard her name was back in '05 when some friends and I went and saw Constantine -- she looks so different than she did in The Mummy! Also, you mention the loads of eyeliner she wore in The Mummy Returns...perhaps that's why I wasn't sure it was the same actress when I saw it.