So, the first season of
The Deadliest Warrior came to a close with the episode "The IRA vs The Taliban." (Thanks to edgehopper for the heads up that the episode had aired. I thought it wasn't on until tonight...)
Ah...yeah. I've made
my objections known about the use firearms and how it should generally exclude ballistics-only soldiers from being "warriors." I renew those objections and the ones I made about weapons that aren't really culturally evolved. Again, a Samurai sword has a history amongst the Samurai warrior class. It evolved to the point where it was replaced by better weaponry. Guns, on the other hand, tend not to have come out of most of the cultures that now rely heavily on them. In this "IRA vs Taliban" match-up, both sides use at least one weapon designed by not just another nation but specifically Russia. That shows you how little effort on the part of the warriors in question went into perfecting those weapons. Again, my objection stems from the fact that
anyone could use those guns to kill. It's not that one culture's warrior-ness that made it so effective.
So there's that. But did they really have to add to it by putting two terrorist groups against each other?
( That's just awkward for all involved. )While I did appreciate a kill counter at the bottom of the re-enactment to help keep track of the remaining forces (something "The Mafia vs The Yakuza" and the aforementioned "Green Beret vs Spetnaz" could have used), I could have done without the codified references. In the opening, the Taliban is referred to as "hard-lined religious extremists" and the IRA is referred to as "bloody urban guerillas who waged a savage war for independence." That's a creative re-imagining of the IRA's role in Northern Ireland if ever I heard one. That's far from the only example, too. The inference is fairly obvious: the IRA are less icky (not really) than the Taliban. While I agree that the Taliban's religious extremisms makes it nigh-impossible to bargain with them, a
lack of religion wasn't exactly the IRA's problem, one; and two, they were pretty damned impossible and extremist regardless.